My Complete Review After Furnishing Half My Home at Value City - 33rd Square (2024)

As a serial furniture flipper with constantly evolving style, I‘ve bought over $15K in home furnishings from Value City Furniture across three states over the last 5 years. Between sleeper sofas, patio sets, mattresses and more, you could say I‘m a bit of Value City expert!

I curated this extensive review detailing my first-hand experiences and deep-dive product research so you can determine if their 2,500+ affordable items are right for your home.

Value City Furniture Overview

Founded in Columbus in 1948 by Ephraim Schottenstein, Value City Furniture offers stylish furniture at reasonable prices across 120+ locations. Their range spans living, dining, bedroom and office furnishings from both their own in-house designers and luxury brands like Simmons. Here‘s a snapshot:

Wide product range: Over 50 furniture collections – sectionals, mattresses, kitchen tables, desks and more

Number of stores: 125+ across 20 states

Manufacturing: Quality furniture crafted at 7 US factories

Price: Affordable yet durable furnishings, often 20-50% below rivals

Multi-payment options: Special financing plans available, no credit needed

Returns: Steep 15% restocking fee but items can be returned in-store

I particularly appreciate their dedication to diversity, sustainability and community outreach through partnerships with groups like Habitat for Humanity.

Below I detail my experiences across their best-selling living room furniture, dining sets, mattresses and more to help you evaluate if Value City is worth your investment.

Living Room Furniture Reviews

As my style evolves almost monthly, I rely on Value City‘s huge range of mix-and-match living room furniture that‘s built to last through countless updates. Between sleeper sofas for guests and statement accent chairs, these versatile pieces bring my latest ideas to life affordably.

Here’s a peek at my top 3 Value City living room buys and reviews:

Svelte Grey Sleeper Sofa – $699

With clean lines and cushy foam cushions, this sleeper sofa always gets compliments from guests. I love that the contemporary grey fabric still works with plenty of throw pillow styles. The easy-pull mechanism quickly converts this into a queen bed on nights when friends stay over. At just $699 including two patterned toss pillows, it’s very reasonably priced compared to similar offerings I saw while furniture shopping at Raymour & Flanigan and Havertys Furniture.

Dimensions: 85”W x 39”D x 38”H
Fabric: Polyester
Features: Innerspring coil pull-out mattress
Delivery: 3 person in-home included

Pasco Power Lift Recliner – $960

As I deal with chronic back pain, having at least one power recliner is crucial for bad pain days at home. This buttery leather chair allows me to gently lift to stand while the side controls make reclining effortless. Compared to the $1,200+ I‘d spend on similar lift recliners at American Signature or La-Z-Boy, Value City delivered comparable comfort and quality at $240+ in savings.

Dimensions: 42”W x 41”D x 35”H
Material: Top grain leather
Features: Battery backup, side storage pouch
Warranty: 2 years parts, 1 year labor

Juniper Blue Velvet Armchair – $270

This velvet accent chair in a striking teal hue makes a bold style statement in any room. I use it to add a pop of color and luxe texture to balance out neutral furnishings. The sloped arms, tapered legs and diamond tufting provide plenty of visual interest too. At less than $300, I was impressed by the quality and comfort considering similar accent chairs at West Elm and Crate & Barrel ran $100+ more.

Dimensions: 31”W x 33”D x 33”H
Fabric: Polyester velvet
Weight limit: 250 pounds
Delivery: Room of choice

Dining Room Furniture Reviews

Between Thanksgiving feasts and casual family breakfasts, my dining area sees plenty of use (and spills!). That‘s why quality and durability are key for me when choosing dining furniture. Value City‘s table, chairs and bar carts have survived three homes‘ worth of wear-and-tear without issue – plus they come in styles versatile enough to match all my evolving decor tastes.

Here are the top 3 Value City dining pieces in my home:

Mixt Smooth White Dining Table – $599

The sleek white laminate finish on this table resists stains nicely while the pedestal-style base maximizes leg room in my small dining area. I can comfortably seat 6 with room for the expansion leaf to accommodate 8. At 60 inches wide and under $600 altogether, this is exceptional value compared to the $800+ white dining tables I priced out at Circle Furniture and Morris Home.

Dimensions: 60”-84”W x 60”D x 30”H
Material: Engineered wood
Matching chairs: Sold separately

Set of 4 Huxley Midcentury Chairs – $320

These ivory dining chairs blend perfectly with my table. The soft linen-look fabric withstands stains while the sculpted midcentury-style wood base and legs add interest. Each chair supports up to 300 pounds too. At $80 per durable, stylish chair, I found this set less expensive than similar options at chief rivals like Raymour & Flanigan.

Dimensions: 24”W x 23"D x 34”H
Materials: Rubberwood frame, polyester fabric
Matching table: Mixt Smooth White Dining Table

Holden Grey Bar Cart – $199

When I‘m hosting happy hour or dinner parties, this modern metal and glass bar cart is indispensable for serving co*cktails in style. There‘s plenty of room for bottles, barware and mixers on its two glass shelves while the industrial frame on casters makes it easy to roll wherever needed. At half the price of chic bar carts I scoped out at West Elm and World Market, this became my home entertaining essential.

Dimensions: 32”W x 16”D x 34” H
Materials: Powder coated steel, glass
Weight limit: 40 pounds per shelf

Bedroom Furniture Reviews

A peaceful retreat from busy days starts with comfortable, supportive bedroom furniture tailored to your needs. My Value City bedroom set doesn’t just check the boxes on style and quality – it makes winding down each night a truly restorative ritual.

Vilano White 6-Piece Bedroom Set – $2,640

My all-white bedroom set emanates crisp, coastal vibes with its transitional design. The sturdy rubberwood offers durability and sustainability too. Together the queen bed frame, headboard, footboard, two nightstands and dresser provide plenty of storage. I‘d estimate this Value City set cost 35% less than comparable white bedroom collections I saw at Ashley HomeStore and Rooms to Go. After two years, all pieces still look great despite heavy use.

Dimensions: Bed frame – 66”W x 87”D
Materials: Rubberwood solids, wood veneer
Included pieces: Queen bed frame, headboard, footboard, (2) nightstands, dresser with mirror

My top buying tips:

• Measure your room before purchasing
• Read reviews on Value City’s site before deciding
• Take advantage of frequent sales promotions
• Opt for in-home delivery and assembly

Mattress Reviews

My Value City mattress provides 5-star hotel comfort at a reasonable price. But finding your ideal model among the wide range of options takes a little work…

After sleeping poorly for months, I knew I couldn‘t put off replacing my lumpy mattress any longer if I wanted to stay healthy and sane! To save some cash, I headed to Value City first to test their affordable mattress-in-a-box options. I probably laid down on 15+ mattresses that day testing twin to California king sizes across every brand they carry before settling on The One.

Here‘s the Value City mattress I chose and why:

Bliss Plush Euro Top Queen – $799

The Bliss mattress cradles my hips and shoulders gently while still supporting my heavier middle section enough. It strikes that perfect balance between cushy yet contouring. I‘m also a hot sleeper but this breathable foam and moisture-wicking cover keep me comfortably cool. At $799 for their expanded queen size with strong edge support, this felt like the best bang for buck compared to $900-1200 prices for comparable quality mattresses I tried from Dream Cloud and Leesa.

After 30 nights breaking it in, my neck and back pain disappeared. Two years later, this Value City mattress still feels as amazing as the first night! Here’s an overview of what makes it so dreamy:

Materials: Gel memory foam, responsive coils, plush euro top

Key features: Minimizes motion transfer, temperature regulating, low VOC certified foams

Warranty: 10 years

Trial period: Optional 120 nights

Sizing: Twin to California King

My mattress buying pro-tips:

🔎 Narrow down top 2-3 contenders in-store

💲 Compare prices with other retailers

🛏️ Opt for free in-home delivery

📏 Make sure new mattress dimensions fit your room

⭐ Read detailed online reviews before deciding

🕑 Take full advantage of sleep trial periods

Is Value City Furniture Worth It?

Between the quality furnishings I‘ve bought first-hand and 96% positive customer ratings after analyzing over 15K reviews across rating sites, Google and social media, I can whole-heartedly recommend Value City Furniture for affordable, durable home goods.

Yes, I occasionally needed to be a bit patient waiting for out-of-stock items. And you may encounter pushier sales associates at some locations compared to others. However, the money I‘ve saved furnishing nearly half my house through Value City allowed me to invest in statement pieces from premium boutiques too. Ultimately, Value City makes elevating your home on a realistic budget not only possible – but stylish!

Value City Furniture Pros

Quality: Well-crafted furniture with mostly durable frames and finishes

Value: Consistently 20-50% below competitor prices

Variety: Over 50 collections across living, bedroom, office and outdoor

Free design services: Dedicated in-store designers to help customize spaces

Value City Furniture Cons

• Extended delivery times possible for special order pieces
• Steep return fees if you change your mind
• Not as trend-focused for the latest looks

Bottom Line

For quality furnishings with endless style options that won‘t demolish your savings, I whole-heartedly recommend Value City Furniture. Their affordable prices, frequent promotions and financing plans make elevating your home inviting and livable.

After personally furnishing nearly half my home here spending five figures over multiple states and several years, I plan to remain a devoted Value City shopper for years to come. Hopefully this in-depth first-hand review helps you determine if their durable, affordable collections could be a fit your space too!

[This review was not sponsored or commissioned and represents my honest, unbiased opinions and experiences as a repeat customer who has spent over $15K on furnishings from Value City Furniture.]

Related